Research Preview

Image description
Research Project Title
Balancing Pastoralist Livelihoods and Wildlife Management in Ngorongoro
Research Purpose:
Other -(Specify)
Principle Investigator:
ingela.jansson@slu.se
Introduction
Lions, a keystone species in the Ngorongoro Conservation Area (NCA) ecosystem, have faced dramatic declines in numbers and range over the last few generations, not only in the NCA but across Africa. This decline is coupled with genetic separation among increasingly fragmented populations. The NCA represents a critical region where the coexistence of wildlife and pastoralist communities poses complex challenges, while also offering an opportunity to study how lions and humans can coexist and explore the concept of "corridors of tolerance." For over 60 years, a long-term demography study has meticulously tracked the lion population in Ngorongoro, providing invaluable data on their ecology and population dynamics. Human-lion conflicts, particularly livestock predation, remain a significant threat, leading to retaliatory killings that exacerbate the lions' plight. To address these conflicts, the Ilchokuti program by KopeLion, based on the Lion Guardians model, has been implemented in the NCA. Alongside this, a Conservation Incentive Program (CIP) was trialed to further promote coexistence. These community engagement initiatives aim to foster human-wildlife coexistence by providing economic incentives for conservation efforts and involving local communities as active participants. Our research focuses on evaluating the effectiveness of these programs in achieving socio-ecological, management, and conservation goals while maintaining and enhancing the long-term lion demography study in Ngorongoro. Through this applied research, we aim to contribute to sustainable models for human-lion coexistence, ensuring the survival and health of lion populations in the NCA and beyond.
Problem Statment
Lions are experiencing a dramatic decline in range and numbers due to habitat loss, prey depletion, and human-lion conflict. Fragmented populations experience increasing vulnerability to environmental and demographic stochasticity and decreasing genetic diversity with lower adaptive capacities, jeopardizing their long-term viability. There is an increasing need to find options for connecting these fragmented populations. Human-lion conflicts present a significant challenge to both lion conservation and pastoralist livelihoods in the NCA and across Africa. Traditional conservation strategies have proven insufficient for fostering sustainable coexistence, leading to frequent retaliatory killings of lions. The Ilchokuti program by KopeLion, based on the Lion Guardians model, and the Conservation Incentive Program (CIP) have been implemented in the NCA to address these conflicts. The Ilchokuti program engages local communities in conservation activities, providing economic incentives for protecting lions, while CIP offers financial rewards for conservation efforts. How effective are these programs in reversing the decline of lion populations and improving community attitudes towards conservation? Evaluating whether these initiatives have led to tangible improvements in community engagement, reduced human-lion conflicts, and contributed to the recovery of lion populations is crucial. This includes assessing changes in lion movement patterns, activity levels, and overall numbers. As we assess effectiveness of conservation strategies on the lion, a low-density, wide-ranging and elusive species, we need comparable measures of population numbers. The Spatially Explicit Capture-Recapture (SECR) technique holds promise, and apart from assessing density of lions across the NCA, we can compare it against the well-known population in the Ngorongoro Crater. Finding more sustainable models for human-wildlife coexistence is essential for broader conservation efforts. This research aims to provide comprehensive insights into the impact and scalability of these programs, promoting sustainable coexistence and the preservation of lion populations in the NCA and beyond.
General Research Objective
The general objectives are to 1) maintain the long-term (+ 60 year) demography study on lion in Ngorongoro Crater and Ndutu, including social structure, home-range use, population dynamics , 2) measure the extent, drivers, and impact of human-lion conflicts on lion ecology including connectivity and genetics, 3) Evaluate the effectiveness of the combined Ilchokuti & CIP Program at achieving socio-ecological goals in the NCA; namely, engaging local stakeholders as conservation partners, empowering local stakeholders to derive tangible economic benefits through their coexistence with lions, and improving community perceptions and attitudes towards wildlife and conservation. 4) Evaluate the effectiveness of the Ilchokuti & CIP CIP Program at achieving lion conservation goals in the NCA; namely, increasing lion presence, numbers, and range within the NCA’s multi-use area and reducing retaliatory lion hunts and killings, 5) Evaluate the scalability of community-engaged incentive-based programs, such as the one we piloted in NCA as a policy tool for promoting human-wildlife coexistence in Tanzania’s protected area corridors, 6) Develop indicators to measure the effectiveness of CIP programs at achieving Global Biodiversity Framework Goals.
Other Details
Clearance# Clearance Date Permit# Permit Date Commencement Date Completion Date
None CST00000905-2024-2024-00963 Dec. 12, 2024, midnight Sept. 11, 2024 Sept. 10, 2027
Priority Research Theme & Areas
Priority Research Theme Research Area
WILDLIFE POPULATION MONITORING Social, environmental and ecological drivers of population dynamics - Priority ( H )
Project Location
Region Wildlife Area District Species

Ngorongoro

Project Researchers
Researcher Role
Ingela Jansson Principal Investigator
George Lohay Co-researcher
Freddie Manongi referee
Sarah Durant referee
Bernard Kissui Co-researcher
Camilla Sandström Co-researcher
Reseach Objectives
Sn Objective Methods Description
1 Maintain the long-term demography study on lion in Ngorongoro Crater and Ndutu, including social structure, home-range use.
Other Individual identification of lions using natural markings; regular visits with aim to see all resident lions and most transients. Population estimated by total count.
2 Assess lion behaviour patterns and indications of adjustments in NCA’s multiuse area based on fine-scale movement patterns, activity patterns, and habitats selected for kill-sites of domestic and natural prey.
Other With permission for up to 8 lions collared assess: Fine-scale movement patterns and Activity patterns between areas of different human impact. Habitat use at kill-sites, identified by clusters from GPS collared lions.
3 Implementing annual survey for lion density across NCA, using the Spatially Explicit Capture Recapture (SECR). Opportunity to compare density estimation by SECR with total count of Crater lion population.
Other Annual 3-month (April-June) intensive survey for lion density across NCA using SECR. Opportunistic search, aided by field staff finding signs of lions. Using SECR to compare lion density in Crater and Ndutu that is estimated with total count.
4 Continue monthly assessment of lion presence across wider NCA study area based on “Ilchokuti’s” (KopeLion’s field staff) lion sign observations and efforts. This is an addition to the shorter-term SECR survey by giving an indication of lion presence
Other Use date and locations of lion sign observations by the Ilchokuti and their tracklog data for measures of mean monthly lion observations, measured against efforts in a general linear mixed model (GLMM).
5 Continued monitoring of lion’s connectivity and dispersal across NCA’s landscape, focusing on the landscape between the Ngorongoro Crater and Serengeti, including genetic structure, diversity, and dispersal.
Other Non-invasive, opportunistic collection of hair, faeces, tissue samples from lions, genotype with SNP to assess relatedness, population structure and genetic diversity). Movements from GPS collared lions, observations of dispersals by known lions.
6 Evaluate the effectiveness of the CIP Program at achieving socio-ecological goals in the NCA
Interview Analyse the household survey from 2023 of villages both within and outside the CIP pilot area and compare with the 2019 baseline survey, along with a series of focus groups and in-depth interviews with key informants and other stakeholders.
7 Evaluate the effectiveness of the CIP Program at achieving lion conservation goals in the NCA; namely, increasing lion presence, numbers, activity, and range within the NCA’s multi-use area and reducing retaliatory lion hunts.
Other Analyse and compare lion conflict events, habitat selection, day and night activity patterns, and use rate across the NCA, both within and outside the CIP pilot area.
8 Evaluate the scalability of CIPs as a policy tool for promoting human-wildlife coexistence in Tanzania’s protected area corridors
Public Archives/Records Identify those corridors where CIPs are most likely to be a feasible and effective conservation tool and develop a “CIP corridor feasibility map” of Tanzania.
9 Develop indicators to measure the effectiveness of CIP programs at achieving Global Biodiversity Framework Goals
Public Archives/Records Conduct a global survey of all incentive-based conservation programs together with our comprehensive evaluation of the NCA’s CIP Program to identify of the key issues associated with CIPs, the key risks and factors in determining their success.
Reseach Attachments
Attachment Name Attachment
Full Proposal TAWIRI_RESEARCH_PERMIT_RENEWAL_I_Jansson_2024.pdf